It is mostly good because currently only very few people can actually get the files from this forum, which is kind of bad. If you want to download, you must upload. You get some points for posting but this is very very little (0.10 points per post) and it's also a Polish forum. And you must upload more than you are allowed to download, which is again rather unfair. And not many people have that many schematics to upload. For example you can upload 5 schematics and if the administrator gives you only 2 points per each schematic you will have max 10 points so you can download only 1 schematic, even if it is old or unpopular. For upload you will get 0-10 points but for download you will always lose 10 point regardless of quality of schematic. I think ratio 1:1 would be good. After all, the administrators check (filter) all uploads so there can't be any cheating.
I think administrators get the most use out of this forum and users not so much. For example I registered here to download files and I do upload also but I have to wait 1 day before they approve my upload and I get only 2 or 3 points for my upload so I need 3 uploads just to download one old schematic which I need. It is too hard to get what you need for your work on this forum at the moment. For me if would be no problem to pay. At least it would be fair and fast. But I don't like to upload my whole collection of schematics just for downloading a few files here. This forum has a lot of files but how can people download ? Almost impossible. If they don't have many schematics to upload (most people don't) then they can't use this forum at all. Maybe with posts ? 100 posts for 1 download file. Not normal.
Also, sometimes there are small files to download, like
POWER BD LS-4851P.pdf [56.17 KiB]. For this 56 KB file you lose 10 points. Very unfair. So I think people will prefer to pay a small ammount to download rather than upload 5 schematics for only 1 download. But I am afraid that the price for 1 download will be 50 EURO on this forum. :-)